The BMW X1 is generally considered the better choice between the two when comparing the BMW X1 vs. Jeep Compass. This assessment is based on several factors, including performance, luxury, and overall driving experience.

The BMW X1 offers a more refined and upscale driving experience compared to the Jeep Compass. It features a higher-quality interior, advanced technology, and a more powerful engine. According to U.S. News & World Report, the BMW X1 has a base engine that produces 228 horsepower, while the Compass's base engine produces 180 horsepower. This difference in power translates to a smoother and more responsive driving experience in the X1.

Additionally, the BMW X1 is known for its excellent build quality and attention to detail. The vehicle is equipped with a range of luxury features, such as a panoramic sunroof, leather seats, and a Harman Kardon audio system. Consumer Reports notes that the X1's interior is "spacious and well-crafted," which contributes to its overall appeal.

In terms of safety, the BMW X1 also has an edge over the Jeep Compass. The X1 received a higher overall safety rating from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), scoring "Good" in all crash tests, while the Compass received "Acceptable" ratings. The X1 also comes standard with a suite of advanced safety features, such as automatic emergency braking and lane departure warning, which are not available on all Compass trims.

While the Jeep Compass offers a more rugged and off-road capable design, the BMW X1's combination of luxury, performance, and safety features make it the superior choice for most drivers. The Compass may be more suitable for those who prioritize off-road capabilities and a more rugged aesthetic, but for those seeking a well-rounded luxury compact SUV, the BMW X1 is the clear winner.