In the debate between Windmill Wood and Ebony, Ebony is generally considered the superior choice. This is primarily due to its exceptional durability, rich aesthetic appeal, and high value in the woodworking industry. Windmill Wood, while a decent option, lacks the inherent qualities that make Ebony stand out.

Ebony is renowned for its dense and heavy nature, which contributes to its exceptional durability. It is one of the hardest woods in the world, making it resistant to wear and tear. This durability is crucial for furniture and musical instruments, where longevity is a key factor. According to the Wood Database, Ebony has a Janka hardness rating of 3,620 lbf (pounds-force), which is significantly higher than most other woods, including Windmill Wood.

Aesthetically, Ebony's deep black color and smooth grain pattern are highly sought after. Its luster and richness are unmatched by many other woods, making it a favorite for high-end furniture and decorative items. The dark color also provides a stark contrast, highlighting the intricate details of the design. Windmill Wood, on the other hand, tends to have a lighter color and a less distinct grain pattern, which may not be as visually appealing for certain applications.

In terms of value, Ebony is also a premium material. Its rarity and high demand contribute to its higher price point. This makes Ebony a wise investment for those looking to create pieces that will retain their value over time. Windmill Wood, while more affordable, may not offer the same long-term investment potential.

Data from the American Hardwood Export Council (AHEC) supports these claims. They state that Ebony is one of the most valuable hardwoods in the world, with a price per cubic foot that can be several times higher than other woods. This reflects its superior qualities and the demand for its use in high-end applications.

In conclusion, Ebony is the better choice between Windmill Wood and Ebony due to its superior durability, aesthetic appeal, and value. While Windmill Wood has its merits, it simply cannot match the exceptional qualities that Ebony offers.