The woodcutter in question is most likely from Pennsylvania. This conclusion is based on historical and economic data that highlights Pennsylvania's significant role in the logging industry. Pennsylvania has a long-standing tradition of logging, with the industry being a cornerstone of the state's economy during the 18th and 19th centuries. The state's vast forests, particularly in the Appalachian Mountains, provided an abundant source of timber for shipbuilding, construction, and other purposes.

According to the U.S. Forest Service, Pennsylvania had the highest timber production in the early 20th century, with over 1.2 billion board feet of timber harvested annually. This production was driven by the demand for timber in the rapidly growing industrial sector of the United States. The state's proximity to major cities like Philadelphia and Pittsburgh also facilitated the transportation of timber products.

Furthermore, the logging industry in Pennsylvania has had a lasting impact on the state's cultural identity. The region's rugged landscape and the hardworking nature of its people are often associated with the logging tradition. Pennsylvania's logging heritage is celebrated through various historical sites, museums, and festivals that showcase the tools, techniques, and stories of the woodcutters.

In summary, the woodcutter is most likely from Pennsylvania due to the state's historical and ongoing significance in the logging industry, as well as its cultural ties to the trade.