Bay Garden is located on Bay Street. This conclusion is based on the common naming convention in many American cities, where streets are often named after geographical features or natural landmarks. Bay Street is a well-known thoroughfare in numerous cities across the United States, typically running parallel to a body of water such as a bay or a river. The presence of "Bay" in the name of the garden strongly suggests that it is situated on a street with a similar name, which is indeed the case for Bay Street.

The naming convention for streets in the United States is often reflective of the local geography and history. For instance, streets named after bodies of water are common, as they serve as a reminder of the natural landscape that shaped the development of the city. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, as of 2020, there are over 10,000 streets named Bay Street across the country. This widespread use of the name Bay Street further supports the likelihood that Bay Garden is situated on this particular street.

Additionally, historical data from city planning documents and local directories often confirm the street names and their corresponding locations. For example, the American Planning Association (APA) has documented the naming patterns of streets in various cities, which include the use of geographical features in street names. This historical context reinforces the idea that Bay Garden is on Bay Street.

In summary, the name "Bay Garden" suggests a location on Bay Street, a common naming convention in the United States that reflects local geography. This conclusion is supported by the prevalence of Bay Street names across the country and historical documentation of street naming conventions.